Subscribe

Social Media Links

Insights

 | 6 minute read

Where Fraud Risk Shows Up in Statutory Audits: Revenue, Judgement and the Failure to Prevent Fraud Lens

The Audit as an Enforcement Gateway | Part 3

In Parts 1 and 2 of our auditors in investigations series, we looked at how statutory audits bring facts, accounting judgements, control issues and evidence gaps into focus where there may be Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act (ECCTA) and Failure to Prevent Fraud (FTPF) implications, and how auditors assess and respond when fraud-related concerns arise. Auditors rarely identify fraud directly through the audit process; more commonly, they probe allegations, anomalies, or internal investigations to understand the financial statement impact, whether relevant controls operated effectively, and whether sufficient appropriate audit evidence exists. This final edition focuses on areas where those questions most often arise in practice.

Fraud risk is not spread evenly across the financial statements. Financial reporting frauds often involve overstating assets or earnings, or the understatement of liabilities; as a result, areas involving revenue recognition and significant management judgement frequently attract audit attention. This is because these areas tend to sit at the crossroads of incentives, management discretion, and audit limitations. International Standards on Auditing (ISA) (UK) 240[1] recognises this dynamic and explicitly calls out two forms of fraud risk, which are presumed for the auditor (others being determined by the auditor’s assessment): revenue recognition and management override.

In this article, we explore these two key areas of fraud risk in more detail, how auditors typically respond to these concerns, and how boards and audit committees can address these risks through their oversight.

Why Revenue Recognition Is a Key Fraud Risk in Statutory Audits

Revenue plays a critical role across financial reporting: It influences valuations, loan covenants, and executive incentives, and often involves considerable judgement. Complex contracts — for example, with multiple obligations, variable consideration, rebates, rights of return, or principal–agent questions — create areas where timing and measurement of revenue may be manipulated to bring revenue forward or overstate performance. Complex products and sales transactions also create a higher risk of fraud as management bias or inadequate controls could improperly influence the application of the principles-based accounting standard for revenue recognition.

For auditors, these complexities raise inherent risk and make it harder to obtain sufficient, relevant, persuasive evidence. Common issues include not identifying all relevant performance obligations or incorrectly grouping performance obligations, incorrect allocation of sales consideration, undisclosed side letters that alter a contract’s true terms, consignment stock recorded as sales, or mismatches in distributor channels. Auditors may not label these as fraud outright, but they may identify them as recurring audit matters requiring further enquiry, particularly where they arise in high-pressure reporting environments or affect the timing or completeness of revenue recognition.

Typical indicators include revenue recognition accounting policy misalignment with the product or service offerings on the company’s website, odd margin movements, large post-period adjustments to revenue or accounts receivables, and inconsistent confirmations from customers or distributors. When these issues persist, they may lead to audit adjustments, enhanced disclosures, control findings, restatements, or, in some cases, modified audit opinions. These may also prompt questions from auditors, regulators, or stakeholders about whether the underlying conduct has FTPF implications.

In response to the heightened risk, auditors expand the nature, timing, and extent of their testing. This can include identifying and reviewing key contracts to gain a detailed understanding of the terms of the contracts, the product offering, and the resulting accounting treatment, sending confirmations to confirm contract terms with the customers, obtaining higher quality evidence of when control is transferred to the customer, analysing returns patterns, performing data analytics for the overall movement between sales, accounts receivable, and cash, and sometimes pulling in forensic specialists. These steps could lengthen the audit process and, in more serious situations, may delay completion while an independent investigation takes place.

Management Override and Judgement: Where Optimism Can Slip Into Misconduct

Similar to revenue, fraud risk frequently emerges in judgement-heavy areas such as impairments, provisions, fair value measurements, contingent liabilities, and long-dated forecasts. Auditors can challenge assumptions, but they cannot replace management’s judgement. This “judgement gap” creates a need for clear evidence, documented rationale, and robust challenge where assumptions have a material effect on the financial statements.

The biggest risk here is management override. Valuation of certain complex financial and non-financial assets and liabilities, manual journal entries, unsupported ageing analyses, unreliable documents, or selective disclosures can bypass well-designed controls. Even rigorous audit procedures can struggle to detect override when it is deliberate and concealed.

Often, relevant indicators appear in public reporting rather than explicit fraud allegations: repeated Key Audit Matters (KAMs) highlighting judgement-heavy areas, disclosures of material control weaknesses linked to override or segregation of duties, or going-concern issues following revenue restatements. KAMs are not adverse findings. However, repeated or unresolved themes may provide a useful prompt for audit committee enquiry, legal review, or further internal challenge.

How Auditors Respond to Revenue Recognition and Management Override Risks

Auditors dig into revenue and judgement areas by recalculating models, stress-testing assumptions, seeking external evidence, and checking consistency across budgets, impairments, and reported results. But, as noted in Part 2, even strong audit work has limits. Sampling, estimation uncertainty, and intentional concealment all contribute to residual risk.

When anomalies persist (i.e. conflicting explanations, contradictory evidence, restricted access to documents, reluctant third parties, or late adjustments that lack a clear rationale), auditors typically expand their procedures and may request a formal investigation. They may also run a “shadow investigation”: an independent assessment (for audit risk purposes) of the scope, independence, evidence base, and conclusions of management or counsel-led investigation. All of this tends to disrupt audit timetables and increase the chance of modified audit opinions if evidence gaps remain.

Revenue and Judgement Concerns That May Trigger an Audit Investigation

Investigations usually stem from patterns rather than one-off issues. Common triggers include:

  • Unusual or unexpected patterns of revenue or margins
  • Unexpected swings in valuations of assets or liabilities
  • Inconsistent application of accounting policies or use of inconsistent methods and assumptions in estimates
  • Multiple large manual journal entries near period-end
  • Conflicting or incomplete third-party confirmations
  • Last-minute, non-standard adjustments to returns, rebates, or provisions
  • Lack of sufficient persuasive evidence or audit trail
  • Restrictions on access to data, systems, or source documents
  • Inconsistent management explanations for certain transactions or accounting treatments

Once an investigation concludes, the audit resumes with additional procedures. Outcomes can range from an unmodified opinion, potentially with an Emphasis of Matter, to qualified or disclaimer opinions where evidence remains insufficient, and in severe cases, adverse opinions for pervasive misstatements. These outcomes tend to draw attention from regulators, lenders, and sometimes litigants.

How Boards and Audit Committees Can Build Resilience Before the Audit Forces the Issue

Boards and audit committees can reduce the likelihood of avoidable audit escalation by reinforcing oversight in the areas auditors focus on most:

1. Stronger Revenue Recognition Governance

Clear policies around contract terms and related accounting, contract risk assessments, tracking of side letters, and legal review of non-standard terms. Contract data should reconcile cleanly with ledgers to remove off-book surprises.

2. Structured Challenge of Key Judgements and Data Used in Accounting for Estimates

Cross-functional review forums, documented assumptions, verified data, version-controlled models and audit-ready workpapers.

3. Defences Against Management Override

Appropriate segregation of duties, locked periods with exception monitoring, dual-authorisation controls for manual journals and forensic-style analytics for unusual postings.

4. Built-In Third‑Party Corroboration

Strong confirmation processes, automated links to proof of transfer of control for revenue transactions, and dedicated repositories for rebates and return rights.

5. Board-Level Early Warning Indicators

A pattern of restatements, repeat KAMs in judgement-heavy areas, ongoing scope limitations or material weaknesses tied to override.

Strengthening Fraud Risk Governance

Revenue and management judgement remain the areas where fraud risks, audit limitations, and regulatory expectations can converge. They are also the places where ECCTA and FTPF considerations may become relevant once anomalies, allegations, or investigation findings appear.

Boards and audit committees can build effective challenge, documentation, and escalation discipline early. Tighter contract controls, more independent challenge of estimates, and robust anti-override measures help ensure that when auditors start looking closely, they find strength instead of red flags.

Ankura’s forensic accounting and investigations teams regularly support counsel, boards, and audit committees as independent advisers in audit-sensitive investigations, including by assessing financial statement impact, evaluating control implications, and preparing findings for auditor scrutiny. Ankura also helps organisations assess and enhance their fraud risk frameworks through the same lens used by auditors and regulators. Addressing weaknesses early not only strengthens governance but positions companies to navigate audits, investigations, and regulatory scrutiny with far greater confidence.

What Else Is Changing in the Controls Landscape?

Explore our latest article, which breaks down how Provision 29 is reshaping expectations around material controls, and what this means for auditors and boards: New Corporate Governance Code Controls Requirements — A Paradigm Shift for Boards and Auditors? – Ankura.com.

References

[1] ISA (UK) 240:  The Auditor’s Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements: https://www.frc.org.uk/library/standards-codes-policy/audit-assurance-and-ethics/auditing-standards/isa-uk-240/

© Copyright 2026. The views expressed herein are those of the author(s) and not necessarily the views of Ankura Consulting Group, LLC., its management, its subsidiaries, its affiliates, or its other professionals. Ankura is not a law firm and cannot provide legal advice.

Let’s Connect

We solve problems by operating as one firm to deliver for our clients. Where others advise, we solve. Where others consult, we partner.

I’m interested in
I need help with